Unfortunately many aunts, uncles, parents, grandparents and godparents buy toys “on price”. In my opinion, it is time to re-think the prescription when it comes to toy buying. It is time to think value rather than price tag. The “true cost” formula might be thought about in terms of cost per unit time of busy play. When thought about in this way a durable, intriguing toy costing $100 may actually be a better value than a $5 trinket that barely lasts for the trip home.
As a concrete example, consider a rugged Amish-built wooden pull wagon in the $200 price range. This item can start as a toy tote for toddlers, advance to an active and imaginative play vehicle for pre-schoolers and even prove valuable and fun for teens and adults. Conservatively speaking, the number of useful lifetime hours of play will exceed 400 hours (just one hour a week for eight years) making the $.50 / hour “true cost” an absolute bargain.
What qualities can one look for in a plaything that will increase its chances of producing good value? Look for toys that are durable, creative and non-scripted, and also encourage back-and-forth interaction. An interactive toy is one that requires child intervention and give-and-take to create his or her own drama. A simple stuffed animal is one example. The cognitive process of inventing the pet’s personality, voice, likes and dislikes builds a bond between child and play toy, prolonging the useful life.
Non-scripted playthings are open-ended, encouraging a child’s own imagination to expose all of the possibilities for use. Wooden building blocks are the ultimate open-ended toy. Your toddler can build a castle with them on one day, then add them as buildings or barriers to a racetrack display, or simply just roll them around. Any toy that can be used as a venue for dramatic play (e.g. a playhouse) or can be added in with other toys (e.g. interlocking blocks) to create new environments will have prolonged useful lives. A plaything that allows a child’s creative juices to flow will not only help develop important critical thinking and social skills, it will provide the type of pride of accomplishment that will make the toy “a keeper”. Construction sets, art and craft accessories, and quality tools (e.g. shovels, kid wheelbarrow, cookware) usually enjoy long play lives and are often passed from child to child.
Think Quality. Steer clear of hugely cost-reduced knockoffs with short or no warranties. A toy may have some of the other great play-value characteristics, but if it breaks, the value shrinks. Traditional mainstays such as rugged tricycles, wood-stake wagons and air-tire scooters have passed the test of time for types of toys enjoyed by many generations. Active play options combined with role-playing opportunities, along with durable construction, make for the best characteristics in a toy when seeking optimum return on investment.
